Last Updated on June 29, 2023
I love making pizza in the backyard on the grill when friends or neighbors visit my place. It gives me so much fun and feels like the party mode is on. If you also feel the same and look for the best pizza pan for grill, you are in the right place!
I’ve reviewed some great pizza pans below that are just perfect for grills.
Some of you might be thinking of; you can cook delicious pizzas indoors. So, why deal of unnecessary botheration, right? Trust me; you’ll never get the same feelings indoors. During summertime, you are sitting in a comfortable chair in the open sky with friends with an ice-cold drink, gossiping around, and waiting for the smoky grilled pizza to eat — Truly a divine feeling.
Most importantly, you’ll get a unique smoky flavor in the grilled pizza that you won’t get in the oven-baked pizza. You and your friends will love it for sure.
So, let’s check out the best pizza grill pan below.
Table of Contents
How We Chose The Best Pizza Pan For Grill?
After spending several hours on the research and based on real user experience, we’ve picked the pizza grilling pans, analyzed them based on real user’s experiences and then reviewed them. Most of the pizza pan we’ve reviewed for pizza grilling are cast iron made and come in different sizes so that you can pick the best grill pan as per your need.
The Comparison Table Of Best Grill Pizza Pan
What to look for in the best pizza pan for grill
If you look at the key features I’ve pointed below; it will help you find the best grill pan that will serve you for years. Let’s check those key points:
You must check the materials of your grill pan. It should come up with high-quality materials. Usually, non-stick or stainless-steel pans are not suitable for grilling. They might warp and can’t tolerate high heat. But cast iron pans do wonders on the grill. They don’t warp in high heat and cook the food with perfection. So, make sure the pan is cast iron made when buying for your grill.
Maximum heat tolerance:
The pan you choose for the grill should tolerate high heat. Typically, cast iron cookware can bear high temperatures. These pans can easily tolerate 500F and more in the oven. It allows you to cook on the cooktops and transfer to the oven for the final finish of the dish without changing the pan.
We have a guide on how to reheat pizza in skillet. This will help you warm your leftovers or frozen pizzas with a crispy crust in a pizza pan.
Even heat distribution is so important for the food to cook well. A pan that comes with a flat base distributes heat evenly. So, make sure the grill pan surface is flat when buying.
Tough you’re looking for the best pan for a grill, it doesn’t mean you will only cook on the grill. If the pan is compatible with any heat source, it allows you to use it in your kitchen after the camp or barbecue party.
The simple cleaning process of the pan will make your life effortless. Cleaning cast iron pans are very easy. All you need some hot water, mild dishwashing soap, and a sponge. Just pour the hot water over the pan, apply some soap and then rinse well. Then your pan is ready for the next use. Don’t wash it in the dishwasher. It will ruin the surface of your pan. It would be best if you season the pan with some vegetable oils after every use.
Pizza pans come in different sizes. Before choosing any pans, you need to consider how much space you have in your grill and oven. If it can accommodate two pans simultaneously, it’s better to have multiple pans. So, you can cook more food in a quick time.
The product you buy should long-lasting. It is okay if the price is a bit higher than other cheap goods. It will not only save your money in the long run but also give you peace of mind.
The grill pan handles should be solid and secure. I like the small size handles because it takes less space in the oven, allowing me to bake two pizzas simultaneously in two different pans. But some users prefer large handles for easy carry. So, it’s up to your preferences.
Usually, the cast iron pizza pans price is not much high. You will get high-quality pizza pans for grill around $30 – $50. You shouldn’t invest more than this amount of money in a cast iron pan. If you can maintain it, this budget pizza pan will serve you for years.
Top 6 best pizza grill pan Review
1. Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Pizza and Baking Pan (13.5 Inch)
Best for a life-time warranty
When looking for the best cast iron pizza pan for grill, this pre-seasoned cast iron is my top pick for the list. Firstly, it comes with premium cast iron which is better than a silicon or stainless steel baking pan. It also provides even heat distribution, so the pizza cooks well and becomes delicious with a brown crust.
If you are looking for a better, smarter alternative to non-stick cookware, this pan can be a real good one for you. Its natural surface is way better and safer for cooking, grilling, searing, broiling, or baking than a non-stick one.
On top of this, it allows you to cook on a versatile cooking surface like BBQ grill, stove, oven, or an open campfire, so you get multiple ways to cook and use it for some other dishes to prepare.
The thing to remember is you shouldn’t put it in the dishwasher. It would be best if you hand wash it with warm water for the longevity of the pan. The great thing is it comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee and a lifetime warranty. So, you can return it if it can’t satisfy you.
2. Home-Complete Cast Iron Pizza Pan-14″
Best for golden crust pizza
Home-Complete cast iron is another excellent pizza pan for a grill that you can’t overlook. Firstly, it ensures fast and even heating so you can make golden crust pizza on the grill for your family and friends.
The thing you should know is gourmet chefs around the world prefer cast iron pan to cook pizza. On top of this, old Italy’s villages and hamlets always used the cast iron pan for baking pizza. So, if you want to get the old world’s authentic pizza flavor, this pizza pan would be the best pick for you.
On the other hand, its longer heat retention feature allows you to grill veggies and meats with perfection. You can also bake, broil, fry, or wok your meats and veggies in this handy pan, so it can also be your everyday use kitchen tool.
Don’t forget it’s super easy to clean. You need hot water to do so. Putting in the dishwasher is not recommended due to its longer lifespan. Previous users are super happy with this pan and also said it is an excellent product for the price. So, you can pick it without any hesitation.
3. Pre Seasoned Cast Iron 16 Inch Skillet
Best for multi-purpose use
If you are looking for a quality pizza pan for outside grilling or camping and also want to use it for everyday cooking after the camp, this pre-seasoned 16-Inch pizza pan would be the best one for you.
Firstly, you can grill a 16 inches large pizza or six hamburger patties in it. Secondly, you can use it for regular cooking purposes as it is 2.01 inches deep, which is perfect for frying bacon, cooking eggs, chicken, and steak.
Most importantly, this cast iron pan works with all cooktops, including induction. So, whatever heat source you are using, you don’t need to worry about compatibility. Don’t forget it can take up to 500F in the oven. It allows you to transfer the food from cooktops to the oven without even changing the pan for finishing like a Pro.
I appreciate its sturdy handles to provide a secure grip when the pan is filled with food. I also like its pre-seasoned cast iron matte black enamel finish interior coating, ready to use right away and easy to clean and maintain.
People who have used it before are thrilled with the product. They said this pan is durable enough for everyday use, and the quality is excellent. It is a kind of product that could last a few lifetimes if well cared for. So, it can also be a great pan for your grill.
4. Amazon Basics Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Pizza Pan, 13.5 Inch
Best for high heat
This amazon basics pre-seasoned cast iron is another top-quality pizza pan for the grill you can’t overlook. Firstly, it allows you to grill, broil, or bake chicken, meat, vegetables with perfection in your backyard or the campfire. Secondly, it makes beautifully browned pizza with a crisp bottom like a pizza shop. So, if you want to make authentic carry-out pizza at home, this pizza pan would be a perfect pick for you.
The pan is 13.5 inches wide and a little over an inch deep, so you can fry bacon, cook steak, eggs, and most importantly, bake pizza and most dough recipes. You can effortlessly press the dough into the pan when cold. It won’t stick to the bottom if you maintain the seasoning properly. Otherwise, you can spray it with a bit of olive oil or refined coconut oil.
Don’t forget the pan is a bit heavy like other cast iron pan, but it will work better than a pizza stone or a non-stick pizza pan for sure. On top of this, it is oven safe up to 500F, allowing you to cook in high heat.
Once the cooking is over, you can wipe it out or follow cast iron cleaning instructions. But putting in the dishwasher is not recommended.
I appreciate the small side handles that take up little space in the oven. But it would be best if you always used hot pads, oven mitts, or potholders when transferring the pan from cooktops or the oven as it’d be so hot.
Previous users are delighted with the product. They said the pan is very sturdy and the quality is high for the price. So, it can also be a good pick for you.
5. Pizzacraft Cast Iron Pizza Pan, 14-Inch
Best for the price
Pizzacraft cast iron would be another excellent pick for you when looking for the best grill pizza pan. Firstly, this pan is perfect for pizza, bread, pita bread, cookies, or other dough recipes. Secondly, it is a great pan for the grill in your backyard or an open campfire. Even more, you can also use it on a gas stove as a griddle. So, this cast iron pizza pan allows you to use it for indoor and outdoor cooking purposes.
On top of this, it heats quickly and evenly, so you get perfect baked goods. Even more, it comes with pre-seasoned, so you don’t need to season it further. You can use it straight away. But if you love brown crust, then apply a thin coat of olive oil or cooking spray.
The side handles are small but grip well. It takes up little space in the oven and helps transport effortlessly from cooktops to oven to table. Don’t forget to use hot pads, oven mitts, or potholders as it would become hot.
This pan is oven safe up to 425F, so it allows you to build your brown crust cheese melt delicious pizza at home.
Caring cast iron pan is very crucial for its longevity. It would be best if you hand-washed it with mild dishwashing soap. But don’t put it in the dishwasher.
Previous users are delighted with the product. They said if you apply a small amount of vegetable oil to the pan’s surface from time to time to add more layers of seasoning, it will serve you in your lifetime. So, you can also take this one for using a prolonged time.
6. A1 Chef Pre-seasoned Cast Iron Pizza Pan 14” Diameter
Best for quality materials
This A1 Chef cast iron is another top-quality pizza pan that will fit in your grill perfectly. Firstly, It allows you to grill chicken and meat, cook bacon, eggs, and flank steak effortlessly, and it will work like a charm. Secondly, you can bake pizzas, make crepes and pancakes and even warm up your last night’s dinner. So, this multi-purpose tool has all the features to become your favorite kitchen accessory.
I appreciate this cast iron pan as it heats up in seconds and comes with excellent heat retention. On top of this, it distributes heats evenly, so you always get well-cooked food. You will love to know that gourmet chefs worldwide use this pan for cooking their most famous dishes. So, now it’s your time to impress friends with your mouth-watering creations.
Once you have finished your cooking, you can effortlessly clean it. Just pour some hot water over the pan and rinse. Then you can apply some cooking oil to avoid rusting and voila.
People who have used it before are thrilled with the product. They said the product is very sturdy and an excellent piece for the price. So, you can take it for your grill.
Thanks for reading the complete guide about the best pizza pan for grill. To sum up, I again mention that the cast iron pizza pans are best for the grill. That’s why I’ve picked and reviewed the cast iron pans mostly. I hope you have found this guide helpful and already selected your desired grill pizza pan. If you haven’t picked yet, you can reread the reviews and pick the one that seems to be perfect to you.